Rating wine is a very personal experience, says Ronald Rens. A wine rating is one individual opinion of one individual taster at one specific moment and we should be modest about the outcomes. I use the traditional 20 points scale where I sometimes add some half-points or even the occasional “+” or “–” when I want to add nuance. I have been using this 20-point scale over the last 30 years and it has served me well.
Château Lafite Rothschild 2018, 1er Grand Cru Classé, Pauillac The big smile on Technical Director Eric Kohler’s face when he welcomed me said it all. The weather conditions at Lafite in 2018 were challenging at first. The summer began very late: on July 16, when conditions changed from “extremely challenging” to “unbelievable” for them in Bordeaux. The vines were saved in that hot August by the reserves of water in the ground. Lafite created beautiful classical wines and Kohler’s secret was, “Not to be overwhelmed by the weather. The terroir combined with the weather and a lot of work gave the concentration, typical for the vintage. But we had to be precise to prevent over-ripeness. A gentle extraction was paramount. This vintage gave us a lot.”
Carruades de Lafite 2018 (18.5+ points)
Subscriber Only Content
A paid subscription is required for access to all content other than the Grapevine section. Subscribe below for access to all Sommelier India articles online and to get the print magazine delivered to your doorstep.
Sign In here if you have already subscribed for access. You can request a password from your account page once you’ve entered your email address. If you are unable to access an article after signing in, it may mean your subscription has expired. For other sign in queries email email@example.com
Cheques should be in the name of Sommelier India and mailed to the following address:
C-320 Defence Colony,
New Delhi 110 024, India
Download our subscription form (PDF) to print and mail with your cheque.